Need Help? Let's Talk!281-251-8888 Texas | 561-285-8888 Florida

medicare irmaa appeal

Medicare IRMAA | Step-by-Step Guide to the Appeal Process

Medicare beneficiaries with higher incomes may be subject to an Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA), increasing Part B and Part D premiums.

You have the right to appeal if you believe there has been a mistake in your IRMAA calculation.  You can also appeal if your financial situation has changed since the tax return the Social Security Administration (SSA) used to calculate your IRMAA.

Understanding the appeal process can potentially save you money and ensure your premium reflects your current financial status.

To start an appeal, you must have experienced a life-changing event that significantly reduces your income.  Life-changing events include retirement, loss of income-producing property, or a reduction in work hours.

Proper documentation is needed to provide evidence of your decreased income will support your appeal.  The necessary forms and documentation vary based on the life-changing event you experienced.

What Is IRMAA?

Medicare includes a feature known as the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount, or IRMAA.  A higher fee is added to your Medicare Part B and Part D premiums if your income crosses certain thresholds.  IRMAA aims to have beneficiaries with greater incomes contribute more towards the Medicare program’s costs.

We’re not supposed to call it a “penalty” ─ it’s a “surcharge.”  But it sure feels like a penalty, doesn’t it ?  If you’re subject to IRMAA, it will be an essential consideration in planning your healthcare expenses.

How is the Medicare IRMAA Calculated?

Medicare IRMAA, or Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount, is determined by your income from two years prior.  Specifically, the Social Security Administration (SSA) uses your Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) to calculate any additional surcharge you may owe.  Your MAGI includes your adjusted gross income (AGI) and certain tax-exempt income on your federal tax return.

What are the IRMAA brackets?

The IRMAA surcharge isn’t a one-size-fits-all figure but varies among beneficiaries in a progressive manner.  It’s calculated on a sliding scale, using six income brackets that provide income thresholds determining if you will pay an additional charge for your Medicare Part B (medical insurance) and Part D (prescription drug coverage).

Your exact surcharge is not a flat rate but a percentage increase calculated by SSA and directly related to where your MAGI lands within these brackets.  The higher your income, the higher the surcharge you’ll pay.  Keep an eye on the annual income bracket adjustments so you’re not caught off guard by changes in your Medicare costs.

These income brackets correspond to higher premiums for higher earners.  Note that IRMAA is determined by your tax return from two years prior.  These brackets change annually, usually to account for inflation.  This means the amount you may pay for IRMAA can vary yearly, even if your income stays the same.  If your income has since decreased due to certain life-changing events, you may have a case for appealing your IRMAA surcharge.

Do I still have to pay the IRMAA if I choose Medicare Advantage?

IRMAA surcharges are applied across Medicare services, so being in a Medicare Advantage plan doesn’t exempt you.  If you must pay the IRMAA, it will be added to your monthly Medicare Part B and Part D premiums.

The Appeal Process for Medicare IRMAA

Medicare IRMAA surcharges can be appealed if you believe there has been a mistake or you believe the decision doesn’t accurately reflect your financial situation.  Understand your rights and the necessary steps to appeal effectively.

Grounds for Appeal

You can appeal your Medicare IRMAA if you’ve experienced a life-changing event that reduces your income, such as retirement, loss of income-producing property, or the death of a spouse. Also, you may contest errors in the income data used by Social Security.

When can I appeal ?

Your right to appeal begins as soon as you receive the initial determination letter. You typically have 60 days from the date of the letter to request a reconsideration.

What documentation will I need to provide ?

To support your appeal, you’ll need to provide documentation such as:

  • A copy of your Social Security IRMAA decision letter.
  • Proof of your life-changing event (e.g., a death certificate, letter from employer regarding retirement).
  • Tax documents reflecting a more recent income if it has decreased since the tax year in question.

How to appeal an IRMAA

If you have been notified that you’ll be charged the IRMAA based on your income, and you believe there has been a mistake or your income has significantly decreased due to specific life-changing events, you can file an appeal.

To appeal, use Form SSA-44, “Medicare Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount – Life-Changing Event” provided by the Social Security Administration.  Be prepared to provide documentation supporting your claim, such as a recent tax return, a letter from your employer, or a death certificate, if applicable.

If your financial situation has significantly changed, you may qualify for a reassessment of your IRMAA.  A major life event affecting your economic status can also qualify you for a reassessment.


  • Appeals must be filed within 60 days of the decision notice.
  • Changes in life circumstances, like retirement or loss of income, are valid reasons for an appeal.

Steps to Challenge an IRMAA

  1. Review the Initial Determination Letter:
    • Read and understand the letter stating your IRMAA surcharge.
    • Identify the reason for the increased premium.
  2. Gather Your Documentation:
    • Prepare evidence of a life-changing event or proof of reduced income.
    • Examples include tax documents, death certificates, letters from former employers, or divorce decrees.
  3. Request for Reconsideration:
  4. Submit the Appeal:
    • Send your completed forms and documents to your Social Security office.
    • Keep a copy of everything you submit for your records.
  5. Track and Follow-Up:
    • Monitor your case.
    • Be prepared to provide additional information if requested.

By appealing, you’re taking an active step to ensure that your Medicare costs accurately reflect your current financial status.  Keep records of all correspondence and make note of deadlines to ensure a smooth appeal process.

After the Appeal: Next Steps

Once your appeal is filed, Social Security will review your case and issue a decision.  If you disagree with the reconsideration decision, you can further appeal by requesting a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge.  During this process, you have the right to be represented by an attorney or other representative.

Ways to Avoid (or Reduce) IRMAA

IRMAA charges can be minimized by carefully planning your finances, specifically around your income.  Here are some ideas about how you can strategically approach this:

  • Income Planning ─ Be aware of the income thresholds that trigger IRMAA.  Plan your retirement distributions or other taxable income to stay below these limits if possible.
    • Timing of Income ─ If possible, spread out significant income over multiple years.
    • Capital Gains ─ Time the sale of assets to avoid spiking your income in one year.
    • Life-Changing Events ─ Report changes like marriage, divorce, or loss of income to potentially adjust your IRMAA.
  • Tax Allowances ─ Take full advantage of tax deductions and credits for which you are eligible, as these can reduce your adjusted gross income.
  • Reducing Taxable Income:
    • Contribute to retirement accounts like IRAs or 401(k)s, which could lower your current taxable income.
    • Consider tax-free income sources such as Roth IRAs or municipal bonds, which are not counted toward IRMAA thresholds.
    • If you own a business, ensure you are maximizing business-related deductions.

Final Thoughts

When managing your healthcare, it’s crucial to align your choices with your medical and financial needs.  Navigating Medicare can be perplexing.  This is especially true regarding details such as the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA).  I’m here to help you make informed choices that align with your healthcare needs and financial circumstances.


Not sure where to begin

Unsure where to begin? Complete the form, and we’ll be in touch.

    By submitting your information, you agree that a licensed insurance agent may contact you by phone or email to answer your questions or provide additional information about Medicare Advantage or Prescription Drug Plans or Medicare Supplement Insurance plans. This is an advertisement for insurance.


    We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent six organizations offering thirty products in your area. Please contact, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options.

    Not connected with or endorsed by the United States government or the federal Medicare program.

    HEARTWISE, a Senior Health Services affiliate
    Senior Health Services affiliate

    Copyright © 2024 HEARTWISE, LLC | Privacy Policy